Season 3 is a story in which Joe and Love are not faithful to one another. Love sleeps with Theo.
And in the penultimate episode, Theo snoops around Love’s bakery. He finds his neighbors Sherry (Shalita Grant) and Cary Conrad (Travis Van Winkle) locked in a glass cage in the basement. They try to convince him that Love murdered his stepfather’s girlfriend, Natalie (Michaela McManus), but he doesn’t believe them.
Nevertheless, Theo searches for the key to the cage so he can free the couple, and that’s when Love returns to the bakery, walking in on him with the key in his hand. Theo tells her what the Conrads said, but he’s still convinced Joe killed Natalie. “I found footage from the day that she disappeared,” He says so to her. “It was Joe. I know what he is. You don’t have to protect him anymore.”
But Love tells Theo to “leave Madre Linda and never come back.”Theo tries his best to get her to join him, but she declines.
“I can’t,” She said. “It’s my family. We can never see each other ever again. You have to promise. Theo, I need you to promise me.”
Love also has Theo give her back the key, assuring him that she’ll free the Conrads as soon as he leaves. But Theo doesn’t make it to the exit: Love hits him with a fire extinguisher, and as he collapses, he tumbles down the basement stairs.